Articles Comments

Pak Tea House » Democracy, Egalitarian Pakistan, History, Identity, Islam, Islamism, Pak Tea House, Pakistan, Religion, Rights, secular Pakistan, secularism » Nations within a Nation – The Search for a Pakistani Nation – 2

Nations within a Nation – The Search for a Pakistani Nation – 2

 By Adnan Syed

“Indeed, world is ruled by little else but ideas.” — John Maynard Keynes

The Two Nation Theory and Inequality in the New State of Pakistan

The two nation theory was primarily based on distinctive majority-two-nations within United India. The distinction was cultural as well as religious, where both of these characteristics freely overlapped each other. Given the dominance of religion within the edifice of the Muslim nation, it was inevitable that religion will form a large part in the new nation state that was carved due to the Muslim nation identity. And given a strong tradition of political Islam within the Muslim body, it was inevitable that the very political Islam will find its way through the vague contours of the shifting idea of an Indian Muslim nation that was formed mainly as a reaction to the changing landscape of nineteenth and twentieth century India.

Since Pakistan was a political unit demanded by the sudden rise in Indian Muslim nationalism in a span of 7 years, it remained a reactive idea. It was an alternative to recognition of the Muslim nation; and when that recognition was denied, Pakistan was born. And this is where the reactive nature of the idea became its own worst enemy. Since events transpired so quickly in those momentous seven years from 1940 to 1947, Muslim League remained focused on their immediate goal of winning recognition of a Muslim nation within United India, it likely never completely delved into the details of governing the new Muslim state.


When the new nation is formed around an ideal of cultural and religious identity, ML leadership found it hard for the new state to not turn and impose the very religious inspired identity upon all who live inside the boundaries of the newly formed nation. The very violation (or the perception of violation) of equality is what gave rise to the newly formed nation state of Pakistan. What Pakistani founders failed to realize was that if the new found state is to repeat the same mistake, its sub nations will feel immediately threatened, in a way similar to how Muslims felt due to perceived Hindu dominated India. As it happened, new nations within Pakistan did quickly rise to protect their interests and ideals.

Suddenly it becomes clear what Jinnah was thinking on August 11, when he all but proclaimed Pakistan as a secular state. He probably had a good idea of what would entail if Pakistan would opt for the route of an Islamic state. He knew firsthand the ferocity of nationalism when recognition is denied and core ideals of nations within a nation are threatened. And he knew well that nationalism based on other identities can be extremely potent and infectious. Proclaiming Pakistan as a secular state did not negate the idea of Pakistan. It was a perfectly sound continuation of an idea of Pakistan that was rooted in perceived inequality. That Pakistan was never a certain outcome was certain. But once Pakistan became a reality, it was imperative that it did not follow the very mistake that became its reason of existence.

Alas, the founding fathers of Pakistan never followed through on Jinnah’s speech of August 11. They either failed to see that precluding all Pakistanis from equality irrespective of their faith and caste will give rise to further nationalism within the new state of Pakistan. Or maybe they naively believed that Islam would allow complete equality to Muslims and non Muslims.

Jinnah was the visible exception as we hear him say again and again that the new nation was not going to be a theocratic state. He clearly said that religion would have nothing to do with the affairs of the state. But we also hear him invoking Islam during the movement for Pakistan. Jinnah used Islam to unite the Muslim polity. This was an expensive bargain; to invoke Muslims as a nation, he had to call on for Islamic principles that Muslims can relate to. Otherwise, the free-flowing multi-dimensional identities of Indian Muslims (cultural, lingual, regional) would overwhelm their collective Indian Muslim identity. He valiantly tried to keep the Muslim nationalism separate from Islamic theocracy. But he probably did not realize that invoking religious bedrock for a nation was that huge of a bargain. To complicate the matters, right after partition, all religious parties jumped into the cracks between Muslim and Islamic nationalism, stoking the uncertainty even further, and highlighting the Islamic angle of the movement at the cost of Muslim nationalism movement.

If Jinnah occasionally wavered in resolving the contradictions between the demands of Muslims and inequality inside a theocratic state, his comrades completely dropped the ball after his death. Within 6 months of his death, the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan was passing a resolution assigning sovereignty to Allah and holding Islamic laws as a guideline for the future constitution of Pakistan. Except one, all of Jinnah’s colleagues voted for Objectives Resolution. By embarking Pakistan on the path of an Islamic state, founding fathers were sowing the seeds of distrust and fears within the nation of Pakistan, which was composed of various sub-nations primarily along ethnic lines. Maulana Abu-al-Ala Moudoudi, who correctly saw the creation of Pakistan as a product of Muslim nationalism (“chaste prostitution” he scoffed once on this very idea) jumped in as the Muslim League failed to follow through on making Pakistan an equal for all Muslim majority nation. MJ Akbar rightly said that Moudoudi’s children wrested Pakistan from Jinnah’s children. But Jinnah’s children repeatedly catered to Moudodi’s children because they never ever realized that negating Pakistan as an Islamist state was never ever a violation of the raison d’être of Pakistan.

Once Pakistan tried to impose Pakistani nationalism with a healthy dose of religion mixed in, minorities either fled the country, or rose against it. East Pakistan rebelled against the unjustness inside the nation of Pakistan, as it feared (rightly or wrongly) that its cultural identity will yield to the religious-nationalist Pakistani identity. East Pakistan was gone within 24 years of the birth of Pakistan.

Recognizing the Nation of Nations that is Pakistan

Still some 63 years after its birth, as Pakistan struggles to define itself as a nation, it is never too late to realize that Pakistan is a nation of many nations. It may also want to hark back to its origins and see that the perception of injustice and failure to recognize the identity of an Indian Muslim nation is what gave birth to Pakistan. That this 160 million strong nation of diverse nations cannot exist if it doesn’t accord equality as equal Pakistanis. However the religious discourse in Pakistan is so strong that even though Pakistan feels its inherent contradictions, it is powerless to do anything about it. There is a violent Baloch uprising going on, and Sindhi nationalism is kept at bay only by a party led by Sindhis that has strong appeal throughout Pakistan. If democracy is derailed once again, there is no telling how ferocious Sindhi nationalism will be against the state of Pakistan.

There are no fast and easy answers to the conundrum that is the Pakistani state. Pakistan did not get here overnight and will not heal quickly as well. However, in my humble opinion, if Pakistan has to survive as a viable state, the strong religious induced Pakistani nationalism that is threatening smaller nations within Pakistan needs to be checked by Pakistanis themselves. This is easier said than done. So let’s start with the basic lessons from history:

1) For smaller nations within the union of Pakistan to have any say, it is imperative that democracy must continue. Too many of unelected leaders (General Sher Ali and others of Yahya’s rule, General Zia-ul-Haq’s Islamist coterie) have reinforced the so called Islamist ideology of Pakistan, thereby threatening the smaller nations within the union, and weakening the foundations of the Pakistani state. Only continued democracy can ensure representation of all nations; allowing proper representation is the first step in recognizing the rights of a nation.

2)  The nation of Pakistan is simply a second derivative of various ethnic nations. There is no top down ideology of Pakistan, except a simple pledge to all of its nations that their culture, language, and rights are guaranteed by the state of Pakistan. Therefore Pakistan must realize that the idea of a religious narrative and a central language for the nation is perceived as a violation of the rights of the very nations that make up Pakistan. And if the history is any guide, perception is everything when it comes to national causes.

 3) Keynes famously said that ideas of economists and political philosophers are more powerful than commonly understood. Indeed, world is ruled by little else but ideas. The idea of an equal and secular Pakistan for all Pakistanis, independent of the religious ideology, is far more powerful than any of us realize. Today, Pakistan still has a free press, a working democracy and an independent judiciary. This environment, if allowed to continue, will spur critical thinking and introspection, and will allow the inherent contradiction of the official narrative to come under intense scrutiny. Eventually, this atmosphere of free exchange of ideas should look at Jinnah and his view on secularism. Our founders talked about Islam as embodying the principles of “equality, fraternity and social justice”. But they explicitly negated theocracy. Their idea of a moderate Islam as a guiding light for a fair and just society was far removed from the theocratic state that Moudoudi or other ulema wanted. Today, we understand the free flowing overlap a bit better that obscured religious and social lines for the Indian Muslim. We can take a step further 63 years later, and say that we do not need to carry the religion bogey carried by our founders to justify equality anymore. Separating religion from politics is the first step towards making all Pakistanis equal.

 4) The birth of a nation state is a result of the binding of a nation around a cause. When a country turns around to deny the very justice for all of its inhabitants in the new state, then it begins living in contradiction. Pakistan’s salvation, at the end, will lie in the lessons gleaned from its birth.


Written by

Filed under: Democracy, Egalitarian Pakistan, History, Identity, Islam, Islamism, Pak Tea House, Pakistan, Religion, Rights, secular Pakistan, secularism · Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

1,224 Responses to "Nations within a Nation – The Search for a Pakistani Nation – 2"

  1. domain Google Chrome Windows says:

    I am genuinely thankful to the owner of this website who has shared this enormous paragraph at at this place.

  2. These days over 900 million men and women in India own a cellular
    phone and are ready to receive bulk SMS. Organizations and organisations the globe more than have realised the massive prospective of interacting with the clientele,
    suppliers and personnel making use of Bulk SMS.
    Bulk SMS in Indore just requires sending out big volumes of textual
    content messages and conveying the message one wants to convey at when.

    We at constantly strive for creating the most of the possible that this technological innovation has. is a major SMS Marketing and advertising support supplier supplying SMS
    communication providers. The Bulk SMS in Indore gateway reaches across borders and connects to all Indian mobile networks.

    Bulk SMS Indore’s only motto is to give a high good
    quality messaging service 24X7X365 that permits the consumers to swiftly marketise & publicize their
    suggestions, items and companies.

    Confirmed to provide service at quite inexpensive cost when compared to others, Bulk SMS Indore is the no.1 Bulk SMS provider in India that
    deals in low-cost and premium SMS Answers.

    We are a best mix of Outsourced Marketing & Affiliate Advertising and marketing which leaves our customer awestruck and offers higher levels of consumer delight not only pleasure.

    Outsourced Advertising and marketing is at the forefront of this notion, delivering operating solutions for both firms and end consumers
    to aid the Wi-fi Internet and cell technologies, which are springing up
    close to us. As our existing flagship items, our SMS remedies are currently being employed in numerous ways to drive new organization versions and
    supply company answers.

    Affiliate Advertising and marketing remains the spine of this notion, our flexibly attentive crew operates 24X7
    towards the good results of our clients’ items, services or idea that our clientele want to convey to their audience.

    Our function is to give realistic solutions about today’s
    technological innovation and to make it foreseeable future proof and use
    new technologies as it comes.

    Most of our solutions are created in-house, or with 3rd party technique integration.
    Because of this, our expertise of the systems permits Outsourced Advertising & Affiliate Advertising and marketing to speedily and
    professionally give results to equally businesses and finish customers.

    As we chat about our solutions, we render services by means of a lot of tools like Bulk SMS (Promotional &
    Transactional), Voice SMS, WhatsApp Posts, Quick Code, Prolonged Code,
    Mass Mail, Skipped Contact Notify (MCA), Interactive Voice
    Reaction (IVR), Toll Free Nos. which spans by way of Non-DND to DND cellular quantities to principal inbox mail delivery to guide
    generation to comments recording to sharing the info to carry out surveys to appear for market
    place growth, focusing on, segmentation, differentiation & integration to
    in the end obtain the increment in whole income.

  3. 後に Google Chrome Windows says:

    バカ高校やバカ大学の知能レベルがだいたい一緒ってヤツだ。 一度家に遊びに行った時は出がらしコーヒーが出てきたしなぁ
    最近はそんなこと気にしない職場関係も多いんだけど、あなたのとこは でも30001円入れたら変に思われるんだろうなぁ 結婚できない男 無料動画

    若かろうが一人あたり2万円オーバー掛かるのに ゴキブリはダメですが回りの女子よりは虫平気かも? 吉田美和 結婚相手
    そうやって、あとに引けなくさせるような背景を利用してるから 上野動物園は、家族連れが多かったです。

    There are some schemes which might be used to find out
    readability. Many of us want to write down our own resume but sometimes
    our own writing skills tend not to meet the corporation”.
    後に 結婚一言 To enhance your chances of , make a
    directory of pluses and minuses about preventing. In other words, while writing this content thought
    the curious questions that will arise within the minds of the readers to read for
    the subject.

  4. Google Chrome Windows says:

    This excellent website certainly has all of the info I wanted about this subject and didn’t know
    who to ask.

    You can calculate keyword-density by dividing the sum of each and every keyword
    from the sum of words inside copy. Technical manuals, technical specification guides, support manuals, implementation guides – all are forms of technical documentation and they are a part from the job.
    Cause of death is truly
    the result of your autopsy, that’s not done ahead of the
    funeral generally. We make certain that we offer the custom
    writing services at the lowest prices possible.

  5. このサイトのアドバイザーの神原響子って、ほんと失礼。サービス業とは思え 披露宴に一人招待する為に2~3万円は最低限掛かるんだぞ
    そういう極端な考え方をするのがアスペって言うんだよw 東京の友達に交通費とホテル代4万出すから来てくれ言われてる 結婚祝いプレゼント電化製品

    まあ生活かかってる人間ばっかりだろうから引き下げさせない事が重要だろうね 心無い嫌がらせ行為ハトメ悲しいです。女性にもいらっしゃる‥止めて下さい youtube 結婚できない男
    一度家に遊びに行った時は出がらしコーヒーが出てきたしなぁ かすみさんも先日深夜‥同性に嫌がらせ(;_;)マナー違反止めて下さいね‥

    But the assistance of content writing in India is regarded as one in the best and top quality.
    Highlight on the benefits of your product or service:
    When you are looking at sales, it is the benefits that sell, rather than the features.
    弟結婚祝いプレゼント You can get a good
    deal of input about what people are interested in, also it will help you find the knowledge to include inside articles
    that you simply are marketing. Another one that doesn’t realize just how much she has mentored me inside the creative parts of life is my daughter.

  6. Wonderful items from you, man. I have consider
    your stuff prior to and you are simply extremely wonderful.
    I really like what you’ve acquired right here, really like what you’re saying and the best way through which you
    assert it. You make it enjoyable and you continue to care for to keep it sensible.
    I can not wait to read far more from you. This is actually
    a tremendous site.

  7. Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I absolutely think this site needs far more attention. I’ll probably be
    returning to see more, thanks for the information!

    However, you’re allowed to include an author bio with the end of the article which allows that you lead
    your audience for a site that may provide more resources for
    them. For example, the 2003 Will Ferrell film Elf placed a person’s who continues to be raised just
    as one elf at the North Pole into real-world New York City.

    Listen for the chirping with the birds,
    and view as leaves rustle within the wind. That gives a ready excuse for why the ebook was rejected, and also all-but guarantees
    that it’s going to be.

  8. Opus FX Mozilla Firefox Windows says:


    This is where you will actually generate profits
    and grow your business; when the leads are converted into an actual sale.
    When marketing with articles you always want to remember to be communicating your ideas and making your points
    within an understandable fashion. Opus FX Each image can be an absolutely
    different picture, a truly different side of you by having an absolutely different backdrop.
    I say occasional because that you do not want
    your students to write a story filled up with

  9. Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this web page daily, this web page
    is genuinely nice and the viewers are actually sharing nice

  10. This paragraph provides clear idea in support of the new people of blogging, that genuinely how to do blogging and site-building.

  11. url Thailand Mozilla Firefox Ubuntu Linux says:

    You ought to be a part of a contest for one of the most useful websites on the internet.

    I most certainly will recommend this web site!

  12. rampage site United States Internet Explorer Windows says:

    Excellent article. Keep writing such kind of info on your site.
    Im really impressed by it.
    Hi there, You have performed an incredible job. I’ll certainly digg it and personally recommend
    to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from
    this website.

  13. What’s up everyone, it’s my first pay a visit at this web site,
    and post is in fact fruitful designed for me, keep up
    posting these articles.

  14. Aw, this was an incredibly good post. Spending some time and actual effort to create a great article… but what can I say…
    I hesitate a lot and never manage to get nearly anything done.

  15. 私達だけの色を、乃木坂らしさを、精一杯 探してきました。

    If you internet search engine optimize (SEO) your organization’s website, you should have
    to adhere to merely a couple of keywords you would like to be found
    with. 初恋 映画
    本田翼 プリクラ During a show he’d eat about 1 KG of metal
    using mineral oil and taking large volumes of water.

  16. The speedy loans for college kids are customized so you can avail
    cherished laptop and go on along with your projects. This, in addition to television, cable, cellular phones in addition to their plans, i
    - Pods and other gadgets absorb a significant amount of your college student’s
    disposable income. Free laptops college students Sony also use a range of great
    laptops which are perfect for college kids, the Sony Vaio is often a great model to get considered.

    For our purposes, the SSID will be broadcast, and a laptop knows the protection key.
    They are lenovo laptops good for college ideal for travelers who desire something small to
    handle, or for kids or college students.

  17. When doubtful, try cleaning a microfiber sofa in an inconspicuous area using a white cloth prior to trying
    a alternate cleaning method in the visible location. For just $99 an evening, we
    stayed inside a Trail Head room with a king size bed, sleeper sofa, whirlpool tub, refrigerator,
    and nice patio. The sleeper sofa dimensions sofa is excellent option as a little space guest
    bed, because you are able to fold it away when it is not in use and you are going to still have
    a regular sofa to use for sitting.

    Using a sofa sectional in the open-concept bachelor
    space is an excellent way to divide the room between living and
    dining or sleeping space. While talking of loveseat sofas, let’s also see concerning the advantages of convertible sofa bed:.

  18. Among broccoli, popular hybrids include Green Comet, Packman, and Premium Crop.

    homeopathy phytolacca decandra berry for weight loss There are some cases when pet owners add the actual plant for their goldfish tank as well as set off
    the Nitrogen Cycle plus it ends up using your goldfish suffering ammonia burns.

    Then, plan out your arrangement whilst the plants are still within the pots they came with through
    the nursery. There have never been any claims of upset
    stomach or diarrhea with cuscuta seed extract.

  19. v3 max years Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    t even eat dairy or eggs the diet program is pretty much out for vegans.

    Getting place based diet supplements will assist you to lose weight faster and also.

    Side effects of atkins diet diarrhea Besides risking your health
    insurance wasting your dollars, weight loss pills can even be dangerous for youths and desperate family members.

    Oz carries on hold a medical license and present advice despite claims that this diet pill study is bogus.
    The Dukin Diet is usually a high protein diet which may not be for everybody.

    Hannity wasn’t done, claiming, “Jon’s problem is he’s got his head to date up Obama’s a** he cannot see clearly. Chromium polynicotinate weight loss v3 max years This existing time speak
    electronic books, Kindle books, i – Pads, i – Phones etc.

  20. The indicator light should flash a time or two then simply stay lit.
    While the hardware specs aren’t the highest, they’re both still powerful and, most importantly, they are both enabled gain access to the new
    4G LTE network. led light bar on jeep flashing light bar for trucks The only speaker the device has
    could be the soundbar, meaning you’ve got to slide the HTC
    Surround open to obtain a clear speaker phone going.

    They haven’t fulfilled their role in your life which leads
    to drama—but only always. This is really a
    very handy utility app that turns your phone right into a flashlight with all the phone’s flash

  21. It has freed me from the preconceived notions that I was somehow sick.

    Turkey, sweet potatoes, pepperoni dressing, black olives,
    mashed potatoes and gravy with pumpkin pie. Whats does medina mean lmfao mean

    Applications that are signed by the Symbian Signed certification program
    can carry the Symbian Signed logo. For something like this that came out of left field the women coped

  22. your United States Google Chrome Windows says:

    You’re now in a position to use the tv screen for presentations, movies
    or games, or perhaps to browse the internet on a larger
    screen. Also, NVRmini 2′s user-friendly design allows users to easily set it up by following four simple steps.
    Hdmi to rca cable best buy

    With football news could there be to make huge noise and go
    gaga in regards to the entertainment that entails it, rhymes of religion may look a bit subdued.
    Radio shack audio switch box your Anyone can simply surf the web and discover out about new perspectives and ideas from about
    the globe.

  23. Blythe Brazil Mozilla Windows says:

    You can certainly see your skills within the work you write.
    The sector hopes for more passionate writers like you who are not afraid to mention how they believe.

    At all times go after your heart.

    webpage – Tracee,

Leave a Reply


× seven = 7

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>