Articles Comments

Pak Tea House » Uncategorized » Indian Supreme Court’s poignant footnote in Kasab Judgment

Indian Supreme Court’s poignant footnote in Kasab Judgment

From Indian Kanoon:

“[45] It is reported that it was at the Taj Mahal Hotel ballroom that, on February 20, 1918, at her eighteenth birthday party, Ruttie had accepted Mr Jinnah’s hand in marriage while the band was playing the Chopin tune, So Deep is the Night. It is also reported that both Mr. Jinnah, the creator of Pakistan, and Mrs. Sarojini Naidu, the President of the Indian National Congress, often held court at Taj Mahal Hotel.

Mr. Jinnah also had an intimate connection with Mazgaon, where the bomb planted by two terrorists in a taxi exploded, killing three (3) and wounding nineteen (19) people. It is reported that Mr. Jinnah devoted Thursday afternoons to visiting the grave of his wife Ruttie at the Khoja Shiite Isna’ashri Cemetry, situated at Mazgaon, Mumbai.

One wonders what Quaid-e-Azam would have thought of the terrorist attack on his favourite city in the subcontinent and especially on Taj Mahal Hotel, with which he had a personal relationship of a very intimate kind.”




Written by

Filed under: Uncategorized · Tags: , , ,

26 Responses to "Indian Supreme Court’s poignant footnote in Kasab Judgment"

  1. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Don’t try to build up any Jinnah the sentimental saint. He was a scoundrel. What he did after getting his Pakistan is important.

    Let us assume that he was all correct in his dealings with the “scoundrels” Gandhi, Nehru etc.

    But what did he do after 14th August 1947?

    Genocide of hindus under his watch (which he did not undo or instruct to undo), Kashmir aggression under his watch, his undermining of the UN resolutions on Kashmir (His attitide was: “what we have snatched, that we are not going to give up, even if it was wrongly obtained”), his disdain for the bangali muslims, his dishonesty in not admitting that his ideas were not going to fruition in Pakistan under islam …

    Jinnah was definitely a scoundrel from what his real performance after August 1947 has been.

  2. Mustansar Saudi Arabia Internet Explorer Windows says:

    A typical fucked up Indian mentality.

  3. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    to mustansar

    “Jinnah was definitely a scoundrel from what his real performance after August 1947 has been.”

    You can’t refute that one. Your name shows that you are a quisling of arabs and their racism. You want to be more arab than arabs. Islam has tyoically raped and lowered your mentality and dignity.

  4. ranjeet India Google Chrome Windows says:

    Mustansar bhai,
    Till the year 1947, Pakistan was a part of the British Empire known as Colonial India.
    Ab us baat ko saath saal ho gaye hain,
    En saath saloun mein aap Pakistaniyon ne
    India ke fucked up mentality se alag hokar kya-kya haasil kiya hai?

  5. Feisal Rahimtoola Pakistan Internet Explorer Windows says:

    Though reostical Jinnah did not know he was being used by British against the Congress most of his later life, despite his selfishness and stubborness, he was not a scounderal. He was disillusioned and quite broken with skills and ethics of his government machinery that he said: Every successive government of Pakistan will be more corrupt and incompetent than the present. Mind you, he died one year and four weeks after division of India. He may have realized that division of India was a mistake going back on which was difficult if not impossible.

  6. Feisal Rahimtoola Pakistan Internet Explorer Windows says:

    Sorry. You had to read reostical instead of egostical in my comment because of a typo!

  7. Ranjeet Pakistan Opera Windows says:

    Ghandi was also involved in gayism .. Being an indian i feel my self fucked up .. divded into bad cast system .. Neech zaat kay achoot

  8. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    to feisal

    Jinnah proved to be a scoundrel – as stated by me clearly – in the months that he was GG of Pakistan (he may have been a brilliant saint earlier, as per Pakistan hagiography!).

    His role in Kashmir, his disdain for hindus who had to leave Pakistan, his insulting attitude towards Gandhi, his megalomania, his non-critcism of his islamofascist followers/users … that proves my accusation.

  9. godsworth India Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Friends
    Please leave all these arguments behind and move ahead with your wisdom. In today’s world if we think of living in dogmatic isolation, we will do more harm than good to ourselves and to our existence. Amin.

  10. romain United States Internet Explorer Windows says:

    I recommend that we not engage with Ahem till he has something worthwhile to say. He is an ignorant person with no sense of history expect a smattering of myths that he has grownup with.

    The more you engage with him, the more you degrade this wonderfull blog.

    thanks

    Romain

  11. Nasrullah khan niazi United Arab Emirates Google Chrome Windows says:

    A guy above is saying Insulting attitude toward gandi,,, oh bhai,,, Gays are always welcomed by insulting attitude,,, gandi was gay,,, so what a gay should expect from other??/

  12. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    to romain

    It would have been nice/fair of you if you had said “first read him and then ignore him (if you can)”.

    Don’t spread any censoring tactics on this blog.

    I don’t insist that you read me or answer me or agree with me – but it is not fair to say that everyone should ignore me.

    I hope you have the human decency to understand this.

    Even RHR (who dislikes me intensely) never said I should be ignored – who are you to say that?

  13. True blue BIHARI Germany Internet Explorer Windows says:

    Monsieur Romain,

    I don’t Know how much history you have read but…Truth is always bitter and if you swallow a bitter pill with a very sugary or sweet drink, it will do you no good.

    Well For your initiation in the history of subcontinent, esp. the bloody partition and the blood of innocents on Jinnah#s and other Muslim Leaguer’s mind, body and soul, I would suggest you read a book written by “Abdul Wali Khan”, son of Badshah Khan: Facts are facts.

    To make things easier for you, here is the link:
    http://www.apnaorg.com/books/english/wali-khan-1/book.php?fldr=book

    P.S. I don’t agree with ‘AHEM’ most of the time because of the way he says it but I agree completely with what he says,.

  14. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    to T B Bihari

    What is it in my form of expression that you don’t like? Can you give some exact details?

  15. True Blue BIHARI Germany Google Chrome Windows says:

    Well, Ahem bhai, no offence but mostly its your choice of words. Reality, by definition and by nature, is harsh. And you almost always chose to depict reality in the most harshest way possible. *Ab ek andhe ko andha kahanaa sachchaai hai lekin us ko surdas bhi to kaha jaa sakataa hai…* You chose to call him “andhaa” and others chose “surdas over andhaa”.
    *Assuming that you know hindi I gave that example in hindi, if not, ask me and I will try putting that in english, in essence.

    Thats my take on your writings. as stated earlier I agree with what you say but the way you say it, puts many people off, including me. Agreed, you speak your mind. But your thoughts must reach maximum number of people and incite and excite them, else your valuable thoughts are of no value…

    Regards

  16. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    to True Bihari

    Thanks for the advice. It is not new to me. What I do suspect however is that many a muslim reads my posts and finds them exactly good and pertinent. And he wishes that islam has such a strong exposer of its fascism. The muslim cannot thank me directly for that. But some have done it even on the PTH.

    A true friend of muslim humans is one who does not praise/defend/justify islam and push the muslims back into the abyss of islamic self-deceit and deceit.

    But thanks for the rare word of appreciation. You have surely witnessed also the hate and ridicule which I have to face on the PTH. It does not hurt me – it hurts those who do it.

  17. foresee Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Next time pakistanis send their next “Kasab-the-killer-and-muslim-hero” to India they will implant an explosive in his body and get him killed by pressing a button from Karachi if he falls in the hands of the indian police. Muslim brain has shown itself to be capable of such allah-pleasing “intelligence” and islam-glorifying martyrdom since long. Small muslim children were sent with bombs strapped on them and the trigger to the bomb was with some adult hero of islam watching from a distance. Allah, this arab-muslim fascist god, be cursed. He will have to pay bitterly for the evil deeds and lies of his followers and worshippers.

  18. Dronacharya Saudi Arabia Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    GODHRA AND POST GODHRA : ONE SCRIPT ONE DIRECTOR. 60 poor hindus were taken for a “Free” excursion to Ayodhya (boarding and lodging + expenses + pocket money). They spent around 2 weeks and were returning back home. The train stopped at a small station (the location was selected months back. all was moving according to the script). The location is a Muslim-majority District. And Lo and Behold : Coach S-56 of Sabarmati Expression burns.

    FROM INSIDE.

    In September 2004, a committee appointed by Railway Ministry headed by of former Supreme Court Judge, Justice U.C. Banerjee, concluded that the fire was FROM INSIDE. Forensic reports indicate that the ill fated coach was burnt from INSIDE.

    Everything was planned according to the dot. When the train was at Godhra Station, another group of RSS/VHP Militants did a diversion-tactic. Laid the groundwork.. perfecting the SCENE. Mischief to create a riot. Godhra is a muslim-dominated small town. One Old Muslim vendor along with his daughter at a small tea stall. The RSS goons lifted the girl and violated her. They abused the old muslim man, beat him up and pulled his beard. The 16-year-old daughter tried to save him from Hindu militants. She kept pleading and begging to them to stop beating her father and leave him alone. But instead of listening to her woes, the Hindu militants lifted the young girl, took her inside their compartment and closed its door….

    YEH HUA HAI.. GODHRA STATION PAR.

    When Sabarmati Express started to move out of the platform of Godhra’s railway station even while the old man was banging on the compartment doors, pleading for his daughter to be left alone, 2 other vendors jumped into the last bogey and pulled the emergency chain to stop the train. By the time the train halted completely, it was about one kilometer away from the railway station.

    These two men then came to the bogey in which the girl was and started to bang at the door asking the militants to release the girl. Hearing the chaos, people in the vicinity near the tracks started to gather near the train. A mob (which included women) now gathered near the compartment and requested Hindu militants to release the girl. Instead of doing so, they started closing their windows. This infuriated the mob and they retaliated by pelting stones at the compartment. That was all that muslims had done.

    The sections beside compartment S-6 on both sides contained VHP militants. They started attacking the mob which had gathered to save the girl, with long bamboo sticks attached to them.

    Godhra train started burning FROM INSIDE in a pre planned and highly calibrated actm so that the Hindu militants could get a pretext to kill, loot, RAPE Muslims.

    PS : Read Bannerjee Report. for evidence.
    — and after doing Godhra (Part I) — Modi does a Post-Godhra (Part II) to divide population and win elections !

  19. bush United States Internet Explorer Windows says:

    kasab is innocent.killers of king mahedra had the masks.in pictures he is shown with kalwa in right hand.court refused the checking of his video through international lab.goverment want to kill him before interogation from pak lawyers.

  20. zameer United States Internet Explorer Windows says:

    kasab is given death while babu bajrangi is given life imprisionment for burning alive 36 women 35 children and one 2 month old baby girl .why.is it because of hindu apartheid justice system.

  21. MilesToGo United States Internet Explorer Windows says:

    both should be given death.

  22. ahem Germany Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Kasab should be handed back to Pakistan. This should have been done long ago. As soon as it was established that he is a pakistani he should have been handed back (along with the bodies of the other 9 killers). The indian govt. lost a good opportunity.

  23. Facts are sacred is a highly misleading and factually inaccurate book.

  24. True Blue BIHARI Germany Google Chrome Windows says:

    YLH, Assuming that you are talking about the same book I mentioned in my earlier comment; this wasn’t expected of you. But then, please do tell me which book isn’t misleading and factually inaccurate???

    Regards

  25. IndianDude United States Google Chrome Windows says:

    @Dronacharya,
    You must be pakistani because you a conspiracy nut. Please stop breeding with mamu’s daughter.

Leave a Reply

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>