Articles Comments

Pak Tea House » History, Jinnah » Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father

Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father

By Yasser Latif Hamdani

Pakistanis like to claim a lot of nonsense about Jinnah. Most recently Hamid Mir of Geo has claimed that Jinnah had willed that Shabbir Ahmed Usmani would lead his funeral prayers. What can one say to such patent nonsense? I suppose Jinnah told his butler, “I have decided that Usmani old boy would lead my funeral prayers” while holding a cigar in one hand, a class of single malt in the other and his pet dog resting in his lap. Ludicrous. There is absolutely no evidence of any kind – primary or otherwise- that seconds such a ridiculous claim. As a counter-question, one may also ask why then a separate Shia funeral was held at the Governor General’s residence? Was that also willed?

It goes without saying that Hamid Mir is in a long line of people who have taken liberties with facts of Jinnah’s life. For example I received another email from Waseem Altaf, who had earlier fallaciously argued that Jinnah had converted to Shiism in 1921 from Ismaili faith to “further his political career” only to be proved wrong when I showed that in fact Jinnah had converted to Shiism in 1901 long before he was in politics and that converting to Shiism as a matter of fact would not have helped Jinnah’s career either in the League or the Congress. It turns out that Altaf Hussain of MQM has recently shown that in fact the conversion was in 1898. The ignorant arguments of Waseem Altaf – amongst the new illiterate lot who want to criticize Jinnah to prove themselves enlightened except they don’t know enough to criticize him for right reasons- were exploded in my post here.

So coming back to the email, Waseem Altaf mian put in subject “this further reveals Jinnah’s character”. Apparently Waseem Altaf has it on the good authority of “the great historian and scholar” Nasim Yousuf that Jinnah received Rs. 600,000 to make Pakistan. This coming from a person who not long claimed- on this website- that the Australian scholar Ian Bryant Wells’ book “Jinnah, Ambassador of Hindu Muslim Unity” published by a reputed Indian publisher was secretly financed by deep state in Pakistan (if only the Deep State adhered to the secularist ideals that the book states to be Jinnah’s politics).   Talk about wild fantasy. Anyway I had read the article by Mr. Yousuf and found it so patently ridiculous that I did not feel the need to respond to it. However if you do not nip a lie in the bud it comes to accepted as the truth, especially with someone like Jinnah who is already widely misunderstood and whose nuanced political efforts are not always easy to explain to a simple mind.  For one thing, there is absolutely no evidence – primary or secondary- to substantiate this utter and total lie nor has Nasim Yousaf provided any substantiation of his claim. A single line is produced and claimed to be from Modern Review’s editorial from December 1946 which is “…Jinnah is receiving 6 lakhs annually from the government of India…”  There are several issues with this.

1. Why does Nasim Yousaf not produce hard copy evidence which is verifiable for this claim? Should be easy enough? After all he claims to have seen it. Why not produce it?

2. Why is the said “excerpt” truncated as if lifted from mid sentence? Surely the words preceding these 9 words and following them are equally important?

3. Why – if this was such a huge revelation – was it not carried by Hindustan Times, Civil and Military Gazette, the Hindu etc which were considered traditional Congress press?

Let us assume- for the argument- that this line actually occurs in the said journal on the said date, is it automatically assumed that this was some sort of illegal gratification? For example Jinnah’s Lahore house was requisitioned by the British Army in 1941 for the purposes of the world war. Similarly Jinnah was eligible for fuel and other parliamentary allowances as a member of the central legislative assembly which he was continuously from 1910 to 1946. So it could be anything (which is why Mr. Nasim Yousaf has omitted the words immediately before and after the said line and the truth of it can only be ascertained if Mr. Yousaf produces the actual primary source in some scanned form or produces the entire context).

In any event Jinnah was held universally by his opponents and admirers alike to be a man of absolute integrity, honesty and incorruptibility.  Dr. Ambedkar, the great untouchable leader, considered Jinnah the one politician to whom term “incorruptible” could be most fittingly applied and who had “never been a soldier of fortune”.  Gandhi, Jinnah’s principal rival, considered Jinnah’s greatest strength his incorruptibility.  Nehru, who bitterly criticizes Jinnah, wrote in his book “Discovery of India” that Jinnah was without the lure of public office or personal gain. H V Hodson described Jinnah as a completely scrupulous man who was beyond question by even his worst opponents.  The list goes on. One may disagree with Jinnah’s positions in the closing decade of the raj, but one can never claim that he was receiving subsidies from the British.


Allama Mashriqi – who or what was he?

However the same could not be said of Nasim Yousaf’s grandfather, Allama Mashriqi who was widely alleged to have been financed by Adolf Hitler and the National Socialists.  Mashriqi had by his own admission met Mr. Hitler in 1926 and had automatically taken a liking to the Nazi leader. His son confirms that in 1934, the fuhrer had sent a special emissary to Mashriqi to help bolster Mashriqi’s efforts to organize the Khaksar Tehreek. UP Legislature spent an entire day’s proceedings discussing Mashriqi’s connections to Nazis during the second world war. Allama Mashriqi was a thoroughly unbalanced and eccentric character though a gifted mathematician and an alright educator. Other than that he was akin to what we call “chun chun da muraba” in Punjabi.  Mashriqi was everything and nothing.  His Khaksar Tehreek was a curious mixture of Hitler Youth and a militant interpretation of Islamic prayer.  Mashriqi’s vision for India was under absolute Muslim rule of one Muslim dictator called the Amir, who would be a cross between Nietzche’s Superman and Iqbal’s Mard-e-Momin and who would be General Muhammad Bin Qasim and Mahmud Ghaznavi reborn. Allama believed in Islamic Puritanism and Social Darwinism, and sought to combine the two with the local version of fascism. Despite this he claimed the Khaksar Movement was non-communal. Later Mashriqi claimed in his book “Aksariat ya Khoon” (Majority or Blood) that Muslims deserved to inherit India because “on average 125 Muslims have died for every Hindu in battle for India since the inception for colonial rule”.  He criticized the Mullahs from the angle of a popular Islamist lower middle class urbanite.  Allama also criticized Averroes and Avicenna for having made pure Islam impure by bringing in Greek philosophy.  Allama attacked Gandhi for his non-violence which he thought was not manly enough and sent Rafiq Sabir to assassinate Jinnah (ironically for not coming to terms with Gandhi in 1944). In many ways Allama and his Khaksars were the subcontinent’s Kharjites.  Mashriqi attacked the Muslim League for not coming to an arrangement with the Congress but in NWFP he bitterly attacked Khan Sahib and Red Shirts for being too soft on Congress and for being in league with the Hindus. After partition he was one of the foremost advocates of absolute Islamisation of Pakistan. Other than that he was – Sir Sikandar Hayat put it- a coward (which he proved when he failed to come to Lahore in early 1940 to carry out the 313 agitation against the Unionist party which he had called and which resulted in the unfortunate deaths of 50 Khaksar youths). Those interested in reading an unvarnished account of Allama Mashriqi and his movement should refer to Ian Talbot’s brilliant “Region and Partition”, which includes a detailed paper on Mashriqi by Iftikhar H Malik, however I will sum it up in one line – Mashriqi was the “Sir” Allama Zaid Hamid of his time – crazy, eccentric and a chun chun ka muraba.

Now enter Mr. Nasim Yousaf, the “historian” and “scholar” whose great works range from export-import to Singapore to the issue of how Jinnah was a British agent and Mashriqi was a great colleague of Gandhi (he was not! Mashriqi was as critical of Gandhi as he was of Jinnah) who worked to preserved the unity of India, which is also not true. In fact it is impossible given Mashriqi’s flip flops, threats etc to determine which side of the fence he fell, unlike Maududi, JUH and Ahrar who clearly and consistently supported the Congress. As for Nasim Yousaf, those who wish to take him to be some sort of a scholar should at the very least watch his regal message to the peoples of the subcontinent – delivered through youtube. That should prove that the apple does not fall far from the tree!



Written by

Filed under: History, Jinnah · Tags: , , , , , ,

1,291 Responses to "Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father"

  1. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board
    and I in finding It really helpful & it helped me out much.
    I hope to present something again and aid others such as you aided

  2. Excellent post. I was checking constantly this weblog and I am impressed!
    Extremely helpful info particularly the closing part
    :) I maintain such info much. I was seeking
    this particular info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

  3. Geri Doretha Google Chrome Windows says:

    This gives you much more keywords inside a short period of
    time than you can get by utilizing the net keyword tools you
    could be familiar with. It has also been proved the internet hosting companies save about
    40% from the energy cost of their client companies.
    Host – Gator has launched: Basic server colocation, Standard dedicated servers, Elite
    server colocation, Pro dedicated servers.

  4. According to Danila Borovoy, Development Director of a leading Ukrainian news portal,.
    99 to the fresh simply $10 annually from then on. Having declared that, it is not
    more likely to be easy selecting the best site hosting want to host your internet site as you will find numerous vendors offering such

  5. Google Hong Kong Google Chrome Windows says:

    I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did
    you hire out a designer to create your theme?
    Fantastic work!

  6. Katie United States Google Chrome Ubuntu Linux says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I really believe that this web site needs a lot more attention. I’ll probably
    be back again to read more, thanks for the information!

  7. Inge United Kingdom Google Chrome Linux says:

    I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this
    post was great. I do not know who you are but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already ;) Cheers!

  8. Theresa United States Mozilla Firefox Ubuntu Linux says:

    Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the
    video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why throw away your intelligence on just posting videos to
    your weblog when you could be giving us something informative to read?

  9. Hi there! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform
    are you using for this site? I’m getting fed up of
    Wordpress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for
    another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  10. France Internet Explorer Windows says:

    Fantastic goods from you, man. I have have
    in mind your stucf prior to and you are simply too wonderful.
    I reaply like what you’ve got right here, really like what you’re sayiing
    and the waay in which by which you are saying it. You are
    making itt enjoyable and you still care for to keep it wise.
    I can’t wait to learn far more from you. Thiss is actually a tremendous website.

    Feel free to surf to my web page: clash of clans hack tool (

  11. Another kind of fatal head injury caused by motorcycle accident is when the brain is
    stirred while there is no open wound in the head.
    This federal funding can currently be used only for
    motorcycle safety training and awareness programs. Even with advancements to motorcycle helmet patterns and enhanced
    public consciousness of the hazards triggered by riding motorcycles without having helmets, a lot of motorcyclists even now decide on to experience with out a helmet if provided the choice.

  12. It’s gojng to be ending of mine day, but before finish I amm reading this impressive post to increase my experience.

    Here iis my website – skin care routine for dry skin

  13. شرکت فناوری اطلاعات متحد با کادر تخصصی در زمینه طراحی و
    پشتیبانی سایت، در چند سال
    فعالیت خود در این زمینه، معیار های اصلی مشتریان برای داشتن
    یک وب سایت حرفه ای را در موارد زیر
    دانسته است:
    طراحی با کیفیت
    کارایی بالا
    امنیت کدها و برنامه ها
    سرعت لود بالا
    امکان مدیریت کامل سایت
    بهینه سازی و سئو
    قالبهای استاندارد برای تبلت و موبایل
    کاربر پسند بودن
    هزینه مناسب
    تحویل بموقع
    پشتیبانی 24 ساعته
    گروه همگام پیشرو متحد موارد فوق را سرلوحه کار خود قرار داده و با این نگرش، سایت هایی در زمینه
    های زیر با مناسب ترین قیمت و در کوتاه ترین
    زمان در اختیار شما دوست عزیز
    قرار می دهد.

    طراحی سایت
    آژانس هواپیمایی
    خبری و …

    علاوه بر آن، در زمینه بهینه سازی سایت
    و سئو تجربه های فراوانی کسب نموده است و می تواند
    شما را در این امر راهنمایی و پشتیبانی نماید.

    جهت کسب اطلاعات بیشتر و مشاوره
    رایگان کافی است با شماره های 0212287101 و 09127005829 تماس حاصل فرمایید.

  14. I couldn’t refraiʝn from ϲommenting. Exceptionally well written!

    my weblog … synergy spanish

  15. Thank you for some other informative site. The place else could I get that kind of
    information written in such an ideal manner? I’ve a project that I am just now running on, and I have been on the glance out for such info.

    My web page – acne scars on back and chest

  16. This is really attention-grabbing, You are an overly professional blogger.

    I have joined your feed and look ahead to seeking more of your excellent post.
    Additionally, I’ve shared your website in my social networks

  17. This will prevent one from being hooked on such games.

    You also don’t need to be worried about any annoying advertising or unwanted toolbars being installed either.
    The gameboard consists of a vast underwater expanse you could maneuver through as a starving shark.
    Parents must teach their children what exactly is good and what’s bad.

    The more complicated free games may let you analyze wind
    and target movements and also present the part of
    conservation as one of one’s concerns. com 2 you can start
    to play unlimited games at no cost without the hassle of downloading
    or installing anything. The free batch of games for Play
    - Station 4 includes Platformer Towerfall and also
    Capcom’s Strider. In the remainder of this write-up we’ll display you how to obtain free
    Wii games. They may also decorate My Little Pony,
    or spice up their dolls in Gown Up Games. You
    also have the power to shift so abruptly between the adventures free games in the web.
    You can select the degree of each game as outlined by your kid’s age.

    Everyone is aware that the most effective online games turn out
    in Korea and Japan first. The only real downside is always that you may not be able to
    save of which, but this really is countered by many new arcades offering passwords and save points to
    enable you to come back and take care of your game later.
    Everything from galactic politics on the role of excellent and evil in society is
    portrayed in A New Hope. You should be moderate enough to decide on a sport that can excite you
    inside long run. However, this will likely possibly sometimes
    reveal to be very an overwhelming process. There are three
    degrees of gameplay, with ten sublevels inside the
    medium and hard difficulties respectively. Firstly, also, they are all free, but there is
    simply a lot to pick from and also the enthusiastic PC gamer will probably
    be able to find something to make sure they’re busy between the extensive range of addictive games.

    Netizens can not have enough of these free goodies.

    You is going to be surprised from the quantity of more journeys you is certain to
    get to perform. It is obviously a fantastic measure to
    ask around and look for sites with good reviews from satisfied customers and gamers.
    Some of those games demand a certain quantity of Wii points
    while other games may be had at no cost.
    There isn’t better strategy to discover than to
    first play a no cost promotional part from the game.
    Gaming industries has now gained more popular considering that
    the wide use of games by children and adults. Be certain to build a set of activities and games to become played while you shop for the Octoberfest party supplies and invitations.

  18. Usually I ddo not learn post on blogs, but I would like to say that this
    write-up vedry forced me to check out and ddo so! Your writing style has
    been amazed me. Thanks, quite grsat post.

    Have a look at my web-site :: free lottery software download

  19. Monetizing a broad range of titles using the long
    tail can be as lucrative as the traditional hit-based approach, significantly boosting our revenues while allowing us to experiment and learn from a huge segment of
    the market that is chronically under-utilized. In this book Zawahiri outlines and prioritizes
    the goals of what he calls ‘the revolutionary fundamentalist movement’.
    In this free app, little girls choose among 200 wedding dresses
    and accessories to dress-up a bride in 3D.

  20. Hi terrific website! Does running a blog similar to this
    require a large amount of work? I have virtually no expertise in coding but I had been hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyway, if you have
    any ideas or tips for new blog owners please share.
    I know this is off subject nevertheless I just
    needed to ask. Kudos!

  21. Are there any other services that can assist you from the supplier such as Voice-Overs, integration and bespoke services.
    Emission control revisions made in 1973 reduced power output by 3 bhp, although the
    engine’s cruising noise levels were reduced. These views will increase your online presence and boost
    your sales and leads.

  22. Wonderful blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News.
    Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
    I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!


  23. Experienced content writer and editor, Jack Olivor has been working with for 3 year.
    They also helped parents of a 13-month-old girl when they were laid off
    from their jobs because of missing too much work to be with her.
    One will likewise identify a broad exhibit of sea creatures here cooked with advanced formulas.

  24. The promiscuous iphone application instrument to help them true skate
    cheats rise in popularity? This is one of the larger issue at
    hand but less cleanup of the character build.

    Feel free to visit my weblog: True skate hack no survey

  25. investigators earlier this month, baffling users and commentators on the Web alike.
    This is an overview of the major hospitals in India catering to medical tourists and what
    you can expect for medical care and medical facilities.
    Then make the loan repayment amount the first priority in your budget.

  26. What’s up to all, the contents existing at this website are truly remarkable for people
    knowledge, well, keep up the good work fellows.

    Feel free to visit my web site :: springleaf financiazl services (

  27. You can either get these games for iPhone and now I am
    plague inc. cheats not in game message board for players looking for slices of cheese.
    QuestingIn this Skyrim guide. This is a nice game or even more.
    In this game, it can be installed on the bottom. Basically, you
    need some games require you to the game, or RTS, although many companies have also gained
    immense recognition for engaging the users are purchasing a ticket online and playing games,
    you may have.

    Have a look at my webpage Plague inc. cheats yahoo

  28. Useful info. Fortunate me I found your site unintentionally, and I am stunned why this twist of
    fate didn’t took place in advance! I bookmarked it.

  29. google United States Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    The handset comes out of the box unlocked, so you can choose
    any network you wish with it, and also offers both a rear-facing 5 megapixel
    camera for video and photo capture and a front facing camera for
    video calls. Penguin algorithm that got rolled out in April,
    2012 almost shook SEO industry. I attempted it a few times, and as addictive as the game wwas with the GOOGLE letters inside
    the maze, I didn’t obsess over it for hours.

  30. You have made some really good points there. I checked on the wweb
    to find out more about the issue and found most people will goo along wityh yojr views on tis web site.

  31. Foster Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say hat I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your
    blog posts. After all I will be subscribikng to your
    feed and I hope you write again very soon!

    Feel free to surf too my website … seo Hoddesdon (Foster)

  32. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts in this sort of house .
    Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this web site.

    Reading this information So i’m satisfied to convey that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed.

    I most no doubt will make certain to do not overlook this site and provides it
    a glance on a continuing basis.

  33. lawn care Google Chrome Windows says:

    naturally like your web site but you need to test the spelling on quite a few
    oof your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to tell the truth nevertheless I’ll surely come again again.

    Feel frde to surf to mmy web bllog – lawn care

  34. MilesToGo United States Safari Mac OS says:


    say you completely purify Jinnah, then what? Will your kids have a better future because of that? Looks like you are trying hard to make an Abdus Salam out of Jinnah. I say make a Muhammed out of Jinnah, thats will pay off better.

  35. Heya i am somebody in charge of in this article. I came across this particular aboard and I to uncover It genuinely beneficial & it solved the problem away a great deal. I am hoping to show one thing backside and also aid people just like you solved the problem.

  36. Angie United States Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    It’s remarkable to visit this website and reading the views of all friends on the topic of this article,
    while I am also keen of getting know-how.

  37. Hello, always i used to check webpage posts here early
    in the morning, since i enjoy to find out more and

  38. Broderick Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    You probɑbly offer flyers ɑnd brochures as downloads from the
    website. Τɦis article ѡill talk aƄout Internet marketing leading tο receiving а master’s degree in Internet marketing online.

    Ƭhe Ƅest method іs to only send οut the emails tօ users whho havе requested
    inclusion աith aan email subsciber lists, սsually termed as
    opt-іn lists.

    Herе iѕ my blog :: cancer therapies (Broderick)

  39. Gorki United States Safari iPad says:

    Dear Yasser:
    Here below is one of the two of my favorite Nehru quotes. Draw whatever conclusions you want to draw from it.
    “So far as the two-nation theory is concerned, we have never accepted the fact that Pakistan was a result of the two-nation theory. It may be so in the minds of the people of Pakistan but we did not agree to it even then. Our position has been that we cannot consider a nation and a religious community as the same thing. Nations contain more than one religious community. Even if all the Muslims in India believed in this theory, we would not accept it or even if all the Hindus believed in it.” –JLN; collected Works

  40. Gorki United States Safari iPad says:

    Son, your retort doesn’t bother me personally but is discouraging nevertheless considering people like you are the future of my country.
    The Spanish writer, Carlos Ruiz Zafón wrote that the words with which a child’s heart is poisoned, whether through malice or through ignorance, remain branded in his memory, and sooner or later they burn his soul. His book ‘The Shadow of the Wind’ is an international bestseller. Read it some day when you are more mature.
    Your words are a living proof of that, and of the havoc that the RSS chaddiwalas are inflicting on young minds in our country. I am close to his father in age (if not older) and Nehru is considered a statesman the world over, yet his idea of a good rebuttal to an argument begins and ends in sexual innuendo, nothing more nothin less. No effort to come up with a witty counter argument, no logic or critical reasoning.
    Then again what else can be expected from the followers of those whose understanding of politics is limited to dividing people into Ramzadas and Haramzadas.

  41. Gorki United States Safari iPad says:

    yet his idea of = your idea of..

Leave a Reply


+ 9 = thirteen

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>