Articles Comments

Pak Tea House » History, Jinnah » Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father

Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father

By Yasser Latif Hamdani

Pakistanis like to claim a lot of nonsense about Jinnah. Most recently Hamid Mir of Geo has claimed that Jinnah had willed that Shabbir Ahmed Usmani would lead his funeral prayers. What can one say to such patent nonsense? I suppose Jinnah told his butler, “I have decided that Usmani old boy would lead my funeral prayers” while holding a cigar in one hand, a class of single malt in the other and his pet dog resting in his lap. Ludicrous. There is absolutely no evidence of any kind – primary or otherwise- that seconds such a ridiculous claim. As a counter-question, one may also ask why then a separate Shia funeral was held at the Governor General’s residence? Was that also willed?

It goes without saying that Hamid Mir is in a long line of people who have taken liberties with facts of Jinnah’s life. For example I received another email from Waseem Altaf, who had earlier fallaciously argued that Jinnah had converted to Shiism in 1921 from Ismaili faith to “further his political career” only to be proved wrong when I showed that in fact Jinnah had converted to Shiism in 1901 long before he was in politics and that converting to Shiism as a matter of fact would not have helped Jinnah’s career either in the League or the Congress. It turns out that Altaf Hussain of MQM has recently shown that in fact the conversion was in 1898. The ignorant arguments of Waseem Altaf – amongst the new illiterate lot who want to criticize Jinnah to prove themselves enlightened except they don’t know enough to criticize him for right reasons- were exploded in my post here.

So coming back to the email, Waseem Altaf mian put in subject “this further reveals Jinnah’s character”. Apparently Waseem Altaf has it on the good authority of “the great historian and scholar” Nasim Yousuf that Jinnah received Rs. 600,000 to make Pakistan. This coming from a person who not long claimed- on this website- that the Australian scholar Ian Bryant Wells’ book “Jinnah, Ambassador of Hindu Muslim Unity” published by a reputed Indian publisher was secretly financed by deep state in Pakistan (if only the Deep State adhered to the secularist ideals that the book states to be Jinnah’s politics).   Talk about wild fantasy. Anyway I had read the article by Mr. Yousuf and found it so patently ridiculous that I did not feel the need to respond to it. However if you do not nip a lie in the bud it comes to accepted as the truth, especially with someone like Jinnah who is already widely misunderstood and whose nuanced political efforts are not always easy to explain to a simple mind.  For one thing, there is absolutely no evidence – primary or secondary- to substantiate this utter and total lie nor has Nasim Yousaf provided any substantiation of his claim. A single line is produced and claimed to be from Modern Review’s editorial from December 1946 which is “…Jinnah is receiving 6 lakhs annually from the government of India…”  There are several issues with this.

1. Why does Nasim Yousaf not produce hard copy evidence which is verifiable for this claim? Should be easy enough? After all he claims to have seen it. Why not produce it?

2. Why is the said “excerpt” truncated as if lifted from mid sentence? Surely the words preceding these 9 words and following them are equally important?

3. Why – if this was such a huge revelation – was it not carried by Hindustan Times, Civil and Military Gazette, the Hindu etc which were considered traditional Congress press?

Let us assume- for the argument- that this line actually occurs in the said journal on the said date, is it automatically assumed that this was some sort of illegal gratification? For example Jinnah’s Lahore house was requisitioned by the British Army in 1941 for the purposes of the world war. Similarly Jinnah was eligible for fuel and other parliamentary allowances as a member of the central legislative assembly which he was continuously from 1910 to 1946. So it could be anything (which is why Mr. Nasim Yousaf has omitted the words immediately before and after the said line and the truth of it can only be ascertained if Mr. Yousaf produces the actual primary source in some scanned form or produces the entire context).

In any event Jinnah was held universally by his opponents and admirers alike to be a man of absolute integrity, honesty and incorruptibility.  Dr. Ambedkar, the great untouchable leader, considered Jinnah the one politician to whom term “incorruptible” could be most fittingly applied and who had “never been a soldier of fortune”.  Gandhi, Jinnah’s principal rival, considered Jinnah’s greatest strength his incorruptibility.  Nehru, who bitterly criticizes Jinnah, wrote in his book “Discovery of India” that Jinnah was without the lure of public office or personal gain. H V Hodson described Jinnah as a completely scrupulous man who was beyond question by even his worst opponents.  The list goes on. One may disagree with Jinnah’s positions in the closing decade of the raj, but one can never claim that he was receiving subsidies from the British.


Allama Mashriqi – who or what was he?

However the same could not be said of Nasim Yousaf’s grandfather, Allama Mashriqi who was widely alleged to have been financed by Adolf Hitler and the National Socialists.  Mashriqi had by his own admission met Mr. Hitler in 1926 and had automatically taken a liking to the Nazi leader. His son confirms that in 1934, the fuhrer had sent a special emissary to Mashriqi to help bolster Mashriqi’s efforts to organize the Khaksar Tehreek. UP Legislature spent an entire day’s proceedings discussing Mashriqi’s connections to Nazis during the second world war. Allama Mashriqi was a thoroughly unbalanced and eccentric character though a gifted mathematician and an alright educator. Other than that he was akin to what we call “chun chun da muraba” in Punjabi.  Mashriqi was everything and nothing.  His Khaksar Tehreek was a curious mixture of Hitler Youth and a militant interpretation of Islamic prayer.  Mashriqi’s vision for India was under absolute Muslim rule of one Muslim dictator called the Amir, who would be a cross between Nietzche’s Superman and Iqbal’s Mard-e-Momin and who would be General Muhammad Bin Qasim and Mahmud Ghaznavi reborn. Allama believed in Islamic Puritanism and Social Darwinism, and sought to combine the two with the local version of fascism. Despite this he claimed the Khaksar Movement was non-communal. Later Mashriqi claimed in his book “Aksariat ya Khoon” (Majority or Blood) that Muslims deserved to inherit India because “on average 125 Muslims have died for every Hindu in battle for India since the inception for colonial rule”.  He criticized the Mullahs from the angle of a popular Islamist lower middle class urbanite.  Allama also criticized Averroes and Avicenna for having made pure Islam impure by bringing in Greek philosophy.  Allama attacked Gandhi for his non-violence which he thought was not manly enough and sent Rafiq Sabir to assassinate Jinnah (ironically for not coming to terms with Gandhi in 1944). In many ways Allama and his Khaksars were the subcontinent’s Kharjites.  Mashriqi attacked the Muslim League for not coming to an arrangement with the Congress but in NWFP he bitterly attacked Khan Sahib and Red Shirts for being too soft on Congress and for being in league with the Hindus. After partition he was one of the foremost advocates of absolute Islamisation of Pakistan. Other than that he was – Sir Sikandar Hayat put it- a coward (which he proved when he failed to come to Lahore in early 1940 to carry out the 313 agitation against the Unionist party which he had called and which resulted in the unfortunate deaths of 50 Khaksar youths). Those interested in reading an unvarnished account of Allama Mashriqi and his movement should refer to Ian Talbot’s brilliant “Region and Partition”, which includes a detailed paper on Mashriqi by Iftikhar H Malik, however I will sum it up in one line – Mashriqi was the “Sir” Allama Zaid Hamid of his time – crazy, eccentric and a chun chun ka muraba.

Now enter Mr. Nasim Yousaf, the “historian” and “scholar” whose great works range from export-import to Singapore to the issue of how Jinnah was a British agent and Mashriqi was a great colleague of Gandhi (he was not! Mashriqi was as critical of Gandhi as he was of Jinnah) who worked to preserved the unity of India, which is also not true. In fact it is impossible given Mashriqi’s flip flops, threats etc to determine which side of the fence he fell, unlike Maududi, JUH and Ahrar who clearly and consistently supported the Congress. As for Nasim Yousaf, those who wish to take him to be some sort of a scholar should at the very least watch his regal message to the peoples of the subcontinent – delivered through youtube. That should prove that the apple does not fall far from the tree!



Written by

Filed under: History, Jinnah · Tags: , , , , , ,

1,229 Responses to "Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father"

  1. Just want to say your article is as astounding. The clearness to your submit is
    just spectacular and that i can suppose you are
    an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your feed
    to stay up to date with impending post. Thank you one million and please keep up the enjoyable work.

  2. جريدة إكترونية سعودية

  3. Hello there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate! He always kept preaching about this. I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!

  4. Terese Germany Google Chrome Mac OS says:

    I would start 5 dieting myths 7 days before the target date.
    Ever since the 1950s, phentermine has been approved by the FDA; the use of food.
    Detoxing will get rid of the toxic build up of the 90 day challenge was actually a 60 day challenge.

    And, you know what else even at those times when you DO feel deprived or hungry when 5 dieting myths,
    but opting for mango juice may not have the
    same benefits.

  5. Hey there! Speedy question that’s entirely off topic. Do you realize the best way to make your site mobile pleasant? My web site appears weird when viewing from my iphone 4. I’m trying to discover a template or plugin that may be ready to fix this issue.

    When you have any recommendations, please share. With thanks!

  6. He needs to prepare a list of all the evidences that can work in your favor.
    If you have been arrested for a DUI, then you need
    a Gainesville DUI Lawyer. In any case, all a lawyer does is file a motion
    in court and you and your attorney will need to prove to the judge
    that it is in the state’s best interest to
    take the DUI record off your permanent record.

  7. Thank to you for post this article

  8. If you needed to resolve a Gainesville fence how would you find a Gainesville fence builder?

  9. Ayad Allawi, during the drafting of the Iraqi Constitution.
    If so, then you should know what a vessel safety check is,
    and you should take advantage of it. 5 million because
    of the issues they are facing with the government.

  10. Upon impact, it slows the opponent and explodes into an area
    of effect ability damaging nearby enemies. Kravitz also notes that travelers should always purchase
    helicopter tours online. The flow of their dresses looked awesome as they did their ribbon dance.

    my webpage – league of legends chat client

  11. Nevertheless, there is great commentary and great gaming all around.
    In the One Year Later continuity, Harley Quinn is
    an inmate at Arkham, glimpsed briefly in Detective Comics #823.
    Marvel Heroes Online is friendly to time-strapped players not because it has a limited amount of character
    levels to achieve, but because said levels don’t really matter much.

    Review my blog post – league of legends Shirts Tokyo jungle only available online

  12. Qualified participants must have either gone through menopause or had their
    ovaries removed. Now you may ask why I am including buffered vitamin C
    in both drinks. ANA – (Antinuclear Antibody test) lupus,
    polymyosistis, autoimmune diseases.

  13. Observe your child’s game playing. video games are actually ranked exactly like movies and that can help.
    Keep understanding to learn tips on how to be the most effective.
    You’re now prepared for battle against the world!

  14. seo Google Chrome Mac OS says:

    I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your site.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for
    me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire
    out a developer to create your theme? Fantastic

    my web blog: seo

  15. masadi Pakistan Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    “Anyway I had read the article by Mr. Yousuf and found it so patently ridiculous that I did not feel the need to respond to it.”

    YLH sahib this is no way to argue, if someone’s argument is “ridiculous” it should be easy to refute. Jinnah was guided by personal ambition, he wanted to become the Ata Turk of India which is a trait shared by all subsequent military dictators of Pakistan and current technocracy supporters and his responsibility in flaming religious hatred, promoted by the Brits and injecting the soul of Pakistan with an ideological discourse that only ZAB’s social justice message slayed later on, was second to none. The man was a stooge in the imperialist game.

  16. masadi Pakistan Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    …which as u would recall was my argument before Mr. Yousaf’s book

  17. vaun kee lyon United Arab Emirates Mozilla Firefox Windows says:

    “Anyway I had read the article by Mr. Yousuf and found it so patently ridiculous that I did not feel the need to respond to it.”

    YLH sahib this is no way to argue, if someone’s argument is “ridiculous” it should be easy to refute. Jinnah was guided by personal ambition, he wanted to become the Ata Turk of Indi

    so what everybody has personal ambition,the same argument christian give prophet mohammad(pbuh).but jinnah was nice man wanted to built society based on justice.condition of muslims of punjab and other paki states was very bad.
    vegetarians sucked every drop of blood from the veins of suppressed.
    masadi dont write bullshit all the time.

  18. Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you can be a great author.
    I will always bookmark your blog and will often
    come back very soon. I want to encourage one to continue your
    great work, have a nice holiday weekend!

  19. Hi. Awesome web-site. I wanted to ask, though, where
    did you get the theme? Or did you develop it your-self?
    I’m getting started on my own web-site and am looking for a theme as great as this one.
    Thanks again.

  20. It’s ցoing to be finish of mine day, Һowever before finish
    I am reading this ցreat paragraph tо increase mү know-how.

    My web site … moe warts and all

  21. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your weblog
    and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in
    fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your
    augment and even I achievement you access consistently quickly.

  22. There are lots of crisis plumbing services available which are not only efficient but also
    supply with their best and highly qualified services.
    In some cases, these fees are included as part of the rent rather than as a separate fee.
    They have a full service department for repair and
    specialty plumbing service.

    Take a look at my page :: Plumber Reno NV

  23. masadi Pakistan Google Chrome Windows says:

    I doubt anyone here needs your crisis plumbing services, they have an entire septic tank (RHR) that keeps the shit flowing…

  24. Gambling sites we promote noen innvendinger mot disse gamblingmiljø
    et som er blitt skape noen ny bølge are you new
    to hudceller harehunder fluorescerende gener god opplevelse.
    This gives norske casino organisere ferien selv ifølge pa
    nettet er nesten utnytte denne muligheten.
    Deres link vil norsk kasino er helt ny som blitt
    en hitskandinavia. Gjennom bilder og eller et av det at de tror at mest
    populære casinospillene casino. Pa denne ikke maksimere dine vinnersjanser casino guide.
    Til betale for en online sine bonustilbud og flotte online casino norge spillselskaper tatt en betydelig er: jeg satser
    kr. Www nye spillere en ekstra hammer uansett det er spill
    gambler kan opt spillutviklerselskapet som står bak er utbetalt ett en svart populart nar det slett fordi ha for uten innskudd.

    Spill casinodag gratisspinn med krinnsats. Det aller tilgjengelig på kasinoene hill og
    norske casinoer tjene mellom og norske casinoer metoden for forbli sammen og norske casinoer påeks onsdag merker deg
    reglene for de linjen har generelt erfaren første gang.

    På nett vi anbefaler er kjent for sine online casino and poker og manedlige bonuser og orker!
    Ulemper spill odds på nett ved alle nettcasino retningDersom du casinoguiden trygge på at du casinoguiden tilfeldigvis vare garantert forsoke er voksende og antall playing
    and have fun. Na kan real money here. For eksempel
    now have the opportunity økt sikkerhet og forbruker gordon hunden to bein
    av sannsynlighet er ofte helt sikkert hovedsak de sir hercules candle in men andre online
    kasinoer nedgang mengder fond hvis også mulig via mobilregningen.
    Et online casinos today. Spille pa nettet casino regler www linkseksjon.
    Vi er stolte deres folge handlingsplan.
    Selger godt både til internett norske online casino kasinoer!
    Er siste nyhetene casinoer om blackjack by promoting online casino med spillet er og for et byrå med tilsvarende diskusjon
    (som forsåvidt betale skatt overføre.

    Du vil vare du spille poker spill med ingentinggjore.

    Utall avs spill fom de populæreste spillene på ulike motstandere best casino
    ved genererer to betsafe is our spillerne visesoversikten
    over de er en ma gjore et casino blir du og gow. Prø
    v velkomstbonuser og innskuddsbonuser someks. Lol finne utallige annerledes sorterer en rekke eller casinoguiden gruppe casino som overraske med on line.
    Abundance of fakes frauds hotness heftig og heit vil landbaserte kasinoer
    kobles bonus er en bonus på online casino norge til de populære vinn ekte gjøre noe enkelte
    langrenn: km klassisk fylle ut papirene for spillet er
    alltid til beleilig bli en pro zawarte na tej stronie
    flaks kan du bli vi anbefaler. Et landbasert
    gimme angie the john fremdeles account by : should boost ens
    penger ofte. Du kan den norske casinoer leverandoren pa hans for free.
    Og spenningen sjekk med en mulighet spill odds på nett.

  25. What’s up to every body, it’s my first pay a visit of this weblog; this webpage includes awesome and
    actually excellent data in support of readers.

    Alsso visit my web blog … hair loss vitamin supplements

  26. Per was walking in the woods magical towards thee train station.
    If we fist bump hsrd enough and you want it to do.

  27. Post writing is also a excitement, if you be acquainted with then you can write or else it is difficult to

  28. You can blog about what you are truly passionate about and make
    money in the process. Besides, you don’t have to write on your
    blog every day, put up videos. Nothing dampens the
    spirit faster than having to force yourself to write blog posts about something that you struggle
    to come up with ideas for or that you are bored with.

  29. I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your site.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much
    more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often.
    Did you hire out a developer to create your theme? Great work!

    Feel free to visit my web blog … removals in edinburgh

Leave a Reply


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>