Kapil Komireddi’s butchery of history on Jinnah
By Yasser Latif Hamdani So complete have been the state sponsored mythologies in the subcontinent that both Indians and Pakistanis are incapable of looking at the past objectively or with any kind of intellectual ability. Consider for example jingoistic Indian columnist Kapil Komireddi’s piece for Daily Beast titled “Pakistan’s Mohammad Ali Jinnah is not Mandela”. As if Jinnah would care he would be compared to Mandela. Nelson Mandela is no doubt a great leader of our times … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Khan Ministry’s Dismissal and Yaqoob Bangash’s Distortions of History
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Owing to my professional engagements with the now famous Youtube Case, I could not respond to the third of Mr. Bangash’s imagining of history. However, as Mr. Bangash has assigned – for extra-credit seemingly- to his students from FC College to troll me on twitter, I am left with no choice but to expose the deliberate untruths that Mr. Bangash has again deliberately passed on through his article. First of all bravo that Bangash realizes that Khan Sahib had lost moral authority to govern and the League was indeed more popular than the Congress. He then goes on to lie- strong word yes but a spade is a spade- when he deliberately distorts the arithmetic of the NWFP ministry. He has subtly subverted the facts in a way … Read entire article »
Merciless Scrutiny: A Short Story about the Elections
By YLH It is the most important scientific progress of the millennium if not human history. A returning Pakistani physicist from the CERN’s Large Hadron Collider, working with some brilliant physicists from LUMS and QAU, finally managed to build a fully functional time machine in late March 2013 making time travel possible. Given the enormous potential of the machine, the caretakers decided that this must be used to ensure that elections are not just free and fair but the best possible candidates are secured by using the Time Machine. Unanimously the Pakistani government decided that the best possible use of the Time Machine would be go back in time and convince the founding father, Mr Mahomed Ali Jinnah, to travel to the future and participate in Elections of 2013. Finally on … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Rebuttal to Yaqoob Khan Bangash’s Rejoinder on Jinnah’s Pakistan
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Mr Yaqoob Khan Bangash has written a rejoinder to my rebuttals both here and in Express Tribune. Once again Mr. Bangash has proved my point about him not having any historical facts to go by. I could not respond to it yesterday given some urgent professional commitments but I think it is time to place on record how Mr. Bangash distorts history with impunity. He also resorted to personal attacks which do not merit a response but should be referred to to show the desperation with which Mr. Bangash has responded to my rebuttals. First thing is first : Yaqoob Bangash has conceded 2 out of 3 points I had raised. The first being of the definition of Muslim which cannot be logically connected to a party that … Read entire article »
Jinnah’s Pakistan : Rebuttal to Yaqoob Khan Bangash
By Yasser Latif Hamdani I usually try and not respond to Mr. Yaqoob Bangash’s Articles because in my opinion for someone who claims to be a historian, he has never had any truck with historical facts. However, there are some contentions that he has made in his article “Jinnah’s Pakistan” published 19.03.2013 in Express Tribune that are so completely off base and historically inaccurate that not responding to these contentions would be unfair to the memory of Mr. Jinnah, the founder of Pakistan. I have also addressed these contentions in my book “Jinnah: Myth and Reality”. His claim is that Pakistan as it stands today is Jinnah’s Pakistan because of the following: 1. Jinnah’s 11 August speech is a one-off speech and that he spoke mostly for an Islamic state. This is false … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Jinnah v. Nehru – who was more democratic?
It is fashionable amongst Pakistanis to point out how “autocratic” Jinnah was as opposed to Jawaharlal Nehru and somehow it was this autocratic behavior on the part of the father of the nation that is the reason why Pakistan is a dysfunctional democracy at best. The truth of course is that Jinnah’s conduct as His Majesty’s Governor General of Pakistan was far more democratic than that of Nehru as his Majesty’s Prime Minister of India and here is why: 1. Section 93/Article 356: The power to dismiss provincial assemblies. This was omitted by Jinnah in GOIA 1935′s Pakistani adaptation but was retained by Nehru. This is significant. Jinnah did not send provincial assemblies packing. His so called dismissal of Khan Sahib’s ministry was necessitated by the fact that Khan sb had lost … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Happy Birthday Mr. Jinnah
Happy Birthday Mr. Jinnah and Merry Christmas At the Karachi Club a night later, Ken Mac’s band played a special request by Muhammad Ali Jinnah — Paul Robeson’s ‘The End’, which the Quaid-e-Azam apparently used to hum while visiting his wife’s grave in Mazagaon, Bombay. … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah, Uncategorized
What Thomas Friedman has wrong on Egypt, Pakistan and India
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Thomas Friedman’s latest piece deserves to be read by every Pakistani, not because it is accurate- there are several glaring mistakes in it- but because it shows pretty much how the world views us- a basket case anti-people state. The important thing that must be underscored is that if the world views it like this it is entirely our own fault. We have made a horrible mess of things in Pakistan. … Read entire article »
Filed under: Democracy, Islam, Jinnah, Pakistan, south asia
The plain Mr Jinnah
By Saad Hafiz: Muhammed Ali Jinnah who founded Pakistan in 1947 was a refined, anglicised and secular Indian Muslim and lawyer. To Indian Muslims he was a man of sterling personal qualities, the Quaid-e-Azam, ‘Great Leader’. To many Indians, Jinnah was an anti-Hindu demagogue and a political shyster, an unyielding humour-less man with a vainglorious nature. To the colonial masters, Jinnah was a worthy adversary who respected British constitutional and liberal political traditions. Jinnah has been described as a highly conventional politician, who can take no credit for original political thinking at any point. His ‘-isms’ were nationalism and liberalism. He began his career thinking within an ‘Indian’ framework, in the sense of nationalist opposition to British rule. Later, he renamed India’s Muslim community a ‘nation’ and continued his opposition from a narrower … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Jinnah and secularism; Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed distorts history yet again
By Yasser Latif Hamdani “Professor emeritus” Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed is the sort who loves to take liberties with the facts. In his article today “Jinnah and secularism” he has resorted to two outright lies which need to be exposed so that people are not misguided. The article began well enough: “The vision of Pakistan Jinnah spelled out on August 11, 1947 is the closest any leader in the Indian subcontinent approximated to an ideal secular state: a … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah, Partition, secular Pakistan, secularism
Akbar Zaidi and the critical re-evaluation of Jinnah
By Yasser Latif Hamdani This morning writing in The News, Akbar Zaidi, a respected economist, called for a critical re-evaluation of Jinnah’s role in Pakistan’s history. Just to re-cap this was business as usual – Jinnah’s democratic credentials are questionable because of his streaks of authoritarianism, his claim to secularism is limited to one speech about mandirs, mosques etc, Jinnah’s Pakistan is at best a half truth and there is no critical re-evaluation of Jinnah in Pakistan which needs to be rectified and so on and so forth. … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah
Hamid Mir, Nasim Yousaf and distorting the image of the founding father
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Pakistanis like to claim a lot of nonsense about Jinnah. Most recently Hamid Mir of Geo has claimed that Jinnah had willed that Shabbir Ahmed Usmani would lead his funeral prayers. What can one say to such patent nonsense? I suppose Jinnah told his butler, “I have decided that Usmani old boy would lead my funeral prayers” while holding a cigar in one hand, a class of single malt in the other and his pet dog resting in his lap. Ludicrous. There is absolutely no evidence of any kind – primary or otherwise- that seconds such a ridiculous claim. As a counter-question, one may also ask why then a separate Shia funeral was held at the Governor General’s residence? Was that also willed? It goes without saying that … Read entire article »
Important Corrective to distortion of history by Viewpointonline
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Waseem Altaf’s article on Viewpointonline (Jinnah “the Quaid”) made some completely inaccurate claims that need to be addressed. Almost every claim in the said article is inaccurate when tested on the touchstone of historical facts. Since Viewpointonline is as closeminded in its approach to dissent as Daily Ummat or LUBP, they are unlikely to publish my rebuttal. Mr. Altaf’s first claim is that Jinnah became a Shia to advance his political career. This … Read entire article »
Commemorating Secular Pakistan Day
By Yasser Latif Hamdani Today is August the eleventh. The government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan has designated this day as the “minorities’ day” because Mr. Jinnah made a speech on this day in 1947 which is interpreted by some as a charter of rights for minorities. The truth is that Jinnah’s famous speech was a clear policy statement of working towards ending distinctions of majority and minority by following a secular policy whereby religion … Read entire article »
Filed under: Jinnah, Liberal Democratic Pakistan, liberal Pakistan, secular Pakistan, secularism




Recent Comments